This post was written on September 15, 2014.
Warning: This post is basically a giant rant against the church. And by "the church" I mostly mean any church I ever attended for any significant length of time (that is exactly four churches in two states).
I was born and raised in a Christian family. When I was very young my family was part of a conservative church in Maryland. It was the conservative nature of this church that eventually led my parents to decide they wanted to leave it. In the end, this led to us moving to California. I don't know everything to that particular part of my family's life, I was only four years old when we moved here. But I know, that had we stayed, I would be a far different person than I am. For one thing, I think I'd be a more solid Christian. Since I was about fifteen, I've struggled with Christianity. I have the unfortunate feeling that the institution of the Christian church has failed me continually since I was about eleven or twelve.
Most egregiously to me, perhaps, is its continual failure to provide any consistent education in being Christian. I know what I'm supposed to believe and I know the basic Bible stories that make up a child's Sunday school education. I can recite the Apostle's Creed (or Nicene Creed) and the Lord's Prayer. I go to church every Sunday. I'm even an active member of my church. And yet every time I go to church, I just feel like I'm faking it. I have given my time and my energy to the church since I was in middle school. And I don't mean just going to church and to Sunday school. I mean volunteering, primarily in children's ministry. And I do not begrudge the church that time. I have some wonderful, and not so wonderful, memories of taking care of children. There are children at the church that I went to from the ages of 9-18 years old for whom I was a regular caregiver in their lives. There are children for whom I was a favorite "adult." I was trusted with newborns when I was thirteen. And I mean NEWborns, babies just a couple of weeks old. There are also children who I solely remember for that one time that he or she would not let me put them down without bursting into tears, not because they wanted me, but because they wanted their mother (or father) and I had been designated "the person who will return me to mommy." I can tell you, after about ten minutes of holding a very healthy two-year-old, your arms get very tired.
Like I said, I do not begrudge the church this time and energy. However, I do feel that I have given and given and given and gotten very little in return. I had consistent Sunday school until I was ten (fifth grade). But in middle school, I got one year out of three before the junior high leader became the high school leader. I joined the high school group in eighth grade, but two and half years later, he and his wife had twin girls after years and years of trying and failing, and due to his wife's medical condition, both of the girls being born healthy and full term was a literal miracle. His attention quickly switched to them. And then I was the oldest non-college student at my church. I was the only one who was my age at my church. The pastor's oldest daughter was a year younger than me, went to a private Christian school, etc. My point with that is that we had very little in common. I am already socially challenged, so trying to be friends with someone with whom the only thing we really had in common was that we attended the same church was pretty much impossible for me.
When I went to college, I finally found the community that I didn't realize I had been looking for. The small group I began attending consisted of people my age, who understood Christianity, who understood the environment we shared. They were silly and weird and serious and intelligent and dedicated people between the ages of 18 and 22. And for me, that was a magical thing. I felt like I belonged with them. But when we started talking about what we wanted to talk about in our group, what book (or topics) we wanted to discuss, I was lost. They had all read most of the Bible. My knowledge of the Bible was, and remains, confined to the stories you hear in Sunday school--Noah, Jonah, Moses, Zachariah, Sarah, Abraham, the tower of Babel, etc. And there I was, surrounded by people who were suggesting we read Judges or Jude or Paul's letters.
I cannot name the books of the Bible, not all of them. That's something that my sisters once knew (I don't know if they still do). But somehow, in all the jumping around and years without teachers, I missed that part. I cannot recite the ten commandments. I know, vaguely, what they are. But I cannot tell you exactly. I know the names of the first five books of the Old Testament and the first six of the New Testament. I know the names of other books, but the only other one I can tell you exactly where it is is Revelations, because it's the last book.
All that being said, I am not saying that I don't believe in the essence of Christianity. I do believe in the Holy Trinity, the Resurrection, Heaven and Hell, etc. I do believe that the Bible is a true account of the Christian faith at the time that it was written. I'm still figuring out the details--where God, not Christianity, stands on current things like gay marriage, or on lifestyle things like financial management (beyond the whole 10% of your income to the church thing, which I believe is right but have never done consistently). I know where I stand on gay marriage (I'm cool with it). I don't believe divorce is wrong, but I do believe that it should be a last resort, excepting cases of domestic violence. I believe that in certain cases, abortion is the right choice. But I'm also of the opinion that it is primarily a personal decision where the line between acceptable and unacceptable abortion is. I believe that a child is a living human being from the moment it develops a nervous system, no matter how primitive. Once that neural tube exists (the precursor to the spinal cord and spine), I believe that the embryo is a human being. I also believe that medically assisted suicide can also be the right thing to do in some circumstances. I believe a lot of things. The problem lies in relating those things that lie outside the realm of faith to faith.
Before I go farther, faith, for me, is belief in some higher power even when there is no proof that such a power exists. My higher power is the Christian God. And, while we're on the topic of faith and beliefs, I believe that many religions are just different interpretations of the same higher power. The God I believe in is an omniscient, omnipresent being who transcends time and space. I'm pretty sure he can be the God of the Jews and of Islam too. For all I know, he is also the pantheon of Hindu gods. What I just said is probably blasphemous, but it's an opinion, not a fact. Everyone is entitled to their own beliefs, and if those beliefs happen to include the one about "my religion being the only true religion" then go for it, just don't kill people over it (you don't get any true converts that way). I don't force my beliefs on anyone and I believe that it would be wrong to do so.
Okay, so, I feel like the institution of the Christian church has failed me. And despite trying to figure this thing out, this is not the first time I've come to a place where I go to church and I dread being there because it all feels fake to me. I feel like a fraud going through the motions of something just to fit in with that community for the sake of having a community. And I hate it. I feel like I'm constantly lying--to myself, to my parents, to my pastor, to the church community. I was raised in a household that most strongly enforces the no lying rule. It sometimes feels as though lying were a worse crime than murder to me. It isn't, but the way I was raised so strongly pushed honesty. And so I wonder, am I even doing the right thing by continuing to go to church. And if I'm not, how do I know what the right thing is? How do I figure out my religion without that community? But also, how do I fit into that community without knowing what I believe?
I want to be honest with the people around me, but knowing that if I do, they'll just pray for me. And right now, prayer isn't enough. I want to learn. I want to be knowledgeable about my beliefs. I want to make educated decisions about my beliefs. But where the hell do I start!? I know that it isn't simply a matter of reading the Bible and praying and confessing and doing devotions. Maybe it is for some people, but not me. If I'm going to be Christian, I don't want to do it behind closed doors and I don't want to do it by shoving it in people's faces. I'm not saying that I want to go out and change the world and convert hundreds of people. I'd be gratified if I honestly changed one person's life and if that person had changed out of their own free will, not because they wanted to get me off their back. The two most important characteristics to me are loyalty and honesty, in that order. And the first tends to beget the second.
UPDATE (October 20, 2014): The topic of "maturity in Christ" came up during the most recent church staff meeting, and I just want to note a couple of things. What I want, the Christian I want to be, is an authentic Christian. One who is always Christian, not just when it's convenient or easy. I don't want to be a church Christian -- someone who only thinks about being Christian while at church -- although, if I'm to be honest, that is what I am right now. And I think that's where the problem lies for me. What I am is exactly the thing I don't want to be, but the prospect of being anything else is so daunting that I don't even know where to begin. Where do I start reading? What do I read? Who do I talk to? What questions should I ask? How do I read the Bible and understand it the way it was meant to be understood!? And how do you pray?